The Outsourcing of Happiness

There is a German word that has made itself quite comfortable in English: schadenfreude—taking pleasure in another person’s misfortune. Its much less familiar opposite is freudenfreude: taking pleasure in another person’s good fortune.

Some time ago, I wrote about our curious tendency to begrudge the success of others rather than celebrate it. Someone gets a promotion, builds a successful business, earns more money, wins an award or otherwise does well, and our reaction is sometimes to look for the qualification. He was lucky. She knew the right people. They already had money. Someone else deserved it more. Why? Another person’s success ordinarily takes nothing from us. There is surely something healthier—and happier—about being able to say, quite simply, good for them.

I was reminded of that subject recently by a CBC Ideas program featuring Shannon Murray, a professor of English at the University of Prince Edward Island. Freudenfreude is one of six principles Murray says she has settled upon for her teaching philosophy. They come from a lifetime of teaching and are illustrated through Shakespeare, but their reach extends well beyond the classroom. More broadly, Murray is interested in hope—not as wishful thinking, but as a way of engaging with a world whose outcomes we cannot control.

The more I thought about her ideas, the more I wondered whether we have developed a peculiar relationship not only with the happiness of others, but with our own. Perhaps we have become too willing to outsource it.

Hope Is Not Optimism

Hope can easily sound like optimism dressed up in more respectable clothing. Look on the bright side. Things will work out. Keep smiling. Tomorrow will be better.

That isn’t the kind of hope Murray is talking about. She speaks of critical hope, an idea that begins with looking honestly at the world as it is. Things may not work out. We cannot control everything that happens to us. People disappoint us. Institutions fail. Illness happens. Careers end. Relationships break down. Wars occur. Economies falter. We get older. Sometimes the pessimist is right. Hope does not require us to pretend otherwise.

As I understand Murray’s argument, hope asks something considerably harder of us. It asks us to acknowledge reality and uncertainty and nevertheless remain engaged in what comes next. I would put it this way: hope is not believing that things will turn out the way we want, it is believing that what we do still matters even though we cannot know how things will turn out. That makes hope less a feeling than a way of living.

Murray approaches that idea through the six principles she has settled upon for her teaching philosophy: return to what you love; cultivate freudenfreude; remember that “ducats are not daughters”—not everything can sensibly be measured by the same currency; beware of efficiency, at least in things that matter; mind the gaps in what we know; and don’t give up the ship because we cannot control the winds. They aren’t a six-step formula for hope. But taken together, they strike me as an unusually useful way of thinking about how hope might be practised in an ordinary life. And they raise an interesting question: are we still sufficiently engaged in our own lives to practise it?

Return to What You Love

Murray’s first principle may be the simplest. When life becomes difficult, frustrating or overly complicated, return to what made something matter to you in the first place. There may be a useful question buried in that idea for all of us. What did you once love doing that you now mostly watch other people do? Did you play a sport that you now only watch? Make music that you now only listen to? Did you draw, build things, write, travel, read, garden, cook, learn or create before life became too busy?

Returning to something we love doesn’t mean becoming exceptional at it. It may simply mean becoming a participant again. That distinction—between participant and spectator—may be more important than we realize. Because we have become exceptionally good spectators.

We Won

Sports provide the most obvious example. Millions of us invest enormous emotional energy in teams whose players we have never met. When our team wins, we won. When it loses, we lost. Strictly speaking, of course, we did neither. We sat in the stands or on the couch. Someone else trained. Someone else competed. Someone else made the putt, scored the goal, caught the pass or missed the shot. Yet our emotional response can be extraordinary. People are euphoric after championships and devastated by losses. A game played by strangers can determine whether someone has a wonderful evening or a miserable one.

I enjoy watching great golfers play golf. There is something marvellous about watching another human being do something extraordinarily well. There is nothing wrong with that. Indeed, Murray’s freudenfreude suggests something quite healthy about taking pleasure in another person’s accomplishment. But there is an important distinction. Celebrating someone else’s success is not the same thing as depending upon someone else’s success for our happiness. One is appreciation. The other begins to look like outsourcing.

Watching Other People Live

Professional sports are only part of an enormous economy built around our fascination with other people’s lives. We follow singers, actors, athletes, billionaires, politicians and influencers. We know about their relationships, weddings, divorces, houses, clothes, vacations, successes and failures. Social media has made the supply virtually limitless. We can spend every available hour watching other people travel, eat, exercise, decorate houses, build businesses, fall in love, raise children and apparently lead extraordinary lives.

There is a strange thing about all of this: Our own life is happening while we watch. Céline Dion’s recent return to live performance is a good example—not because there is anything wrong with Céline Dion or with wanting to see her. Quite the contrary. Her return after serious illness is an extraordinary human story, and seeing a great performer do something few people in the world can do may be worth every penny.

But consider what happens around the superstar. Thousands fill an arena. Many travel considerable distances. There are flights, hotels, restaurants, tickets and merchandise. Some pay enormous sums for particularly desirable seats or resale tickets. All for a few hours in proximity to someone else’s extraordinary accomplishment.

There is an interesting paradox in that. We tell ourselves that extraordinary success is beyond our reach, and then spend extraordinary amounts of our own money to stand close to someone who achieved it. Perhaps it is worth every dollar. But perhaps it is also worth occasionally asking what we are buying—and what else we might have done with the same resources.

The Outsourcing Economy

Superstars earn extraordinary amounts because millions of ordinary people willingly transfer some of their money to participate in the superstar’s success. The professional athlete’s enormous salary ultimately exists because people buy tickets, television packages, subscriptions, jerseys, advertised products and all the rest. The enormous economics surrounding a superstar performer exist because millions will pay to participate in the experience.

We have created an extraordinary economy around outsourced happiness. We make a relatively small number of people fabulously wealthy by paying for the privilege of watching them do things at which they are extraordinarily good. Then, having helped make their lives extraordinary, we go home and continue watching them live those lives.

That may sound more judgmental than I intend it to be. Entertainment has value. Shared experiences have value. Watching excellence has value. Sometimes an evening at a concert is worth far more to us than whatever else the money might have purchased. The point isn’t that we shouldn’t spend the money. It is that we should occasionally notice that we are spending it. And money may be the lesser cost.

What About the Time?

Time is different from money. We can earn more money. Nobody has yet discovered a way to earn another Saturday.

Consider the hours we can devote over a lifetime to watching professional sports, following celebrities, scrolling through social media, watching interviews and highlights, reading about people we don’t know and debating their accomplishments with other people who don’t know them either. A Sunday afternoon doesn’t seem like much. Neither does an evening. But multiply those hours by 10, 20, 40 or 60 years. What might we have done with even a fraction of them? Learned an instrument. Read. Written something. Learned another language. Built something. Started a business. Volunteered. Travelled. Made a new friend. Spent more time with our children or grandchildren. Played golf instead of watching golf.

The point isn’t to turn leisure into another productivity contest. Sometimes spending Sunday afternoon watching golf is exactly what we want to do. But perhaps there is a useful question to ask from time to time: how much of my discretionary time and money am I investing in experiences created by other people, and how much am I investing in experiences of my own? There is no correct percentage. The value may simply be in asking.

“Ducats Are Not Daughters”

This is where another of Murray’s principles becomes particularly important. We measure almost everything. Income. Rankings. Test scores. Sales. Followers. Likes. Championships. Awards. Productivity. Billable hours. Net worth. The superstar world is wonderfully measurable. Céline Dion can sell a certain number of tickets. A golfer has a world ranking. An athlete has statistics. A social-media celebrity has followers. A billionaire has a net worth. Then, consciously or otherwise, we compare those measurements with our own. It is an absurd contest. There are billions of people in the world, and modern technology allows us to compare ourselves continually with the tiny handful who are the very best, richest, most famous or most beautiful. Naturally, we lose.

But perhaps the problem isn’t our performance. Perhaps we’re keeping score with the wrong scoreboard. Murray borrows from Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice the reminder that “ducats are not daughters.” Some things simply cannot be valued in the same currency. How do we measure being a good grandfather? What is the world ranking for friendship? How many points do we award for being someone others can depend upon? Where are the statistics for curiosity, kindness, judgment, wisdom or courage? How do we measure a marriage in which two people remain genuinely happy together for decades? Some of the most important things in life have terrible metrics. Perhaps one of the distortions of celebrity culture is that it persuades us to measure our largely unmeasurable lives against the highly measurable accomplishments of extraordinary people.

We Have Confused Worthwhile With World-Class

That may also help explain the attraction of living vicariously. If I cannot win the Masters, I can identify with the golfer who does. If I cannot perform before 50,000 people, I can buy a ticket and participate in the experience. If I cannot win the Stanley Cup, my team can win it for me. Their extraordinary accomplishment becomes, for a moment, ours.

But why did becoming extraordinary become the price of participating at all? If I cannot become Céline Dion, why shouldn’t I sing? If I cannot play on the PGA Tour, why shouldn’t I try to become a better golfer? If nobody will publish my novel, why shouldn’t I write it? If I’ll never become a billionaire, why shouldn’t I build something? We have confused worthwhile with world-class. They are not remotely the same thing.

Beware of Efficiency

Murray’s warning about efficiency may be particularly useful here. Much of what makes our own lives meaningful is spectacularly inefficient. Learning an instrument takes years. Becoming good at a sport takes years. Building a friendship takes years. Mentoring someone takes years. A good marriage may take a lifetime. Becoming genuinely knowledgeable about almost anything requires enormous amounts of time that cannot readily be justified by a productivity calculation.

Outsourcing offers an efficient alternative. In two hours at a concert, we can experience the product of decades of another person’s work. In four hours watching the Masters, we can watch abilities accumulated through thousands upon thousands of hours of practice. Perhaps that is part of what we purchase: the emotional dividend from someone else’s investment.

Watching is efficient. Doing is inefficient. But only one changes us. So perhaps we should occasionally do something deliberately inefficient. Read a book that won’t advance your career. Learn something you have no intention of monetizing. Spend an afternoon becoming marginally better at a game you will never master. Have a long conversation that accomplishes nothing except knowing someone better. Make something nobody needs. Do something simply because you enjoy doing it. That may not be wasted time at all.

Be Willing to Be Bad at Something

Being a spectator also protects us from being a beginner. Watching excellence is comfortable. Attempting something ourselves can be uncomfortable. We watch someone who has spent 30 years mastering a skill and compare the result with what we would look like on our first day. That comparison can stop us before we begin.

Perhaps this becomes more difficult as we get older and more accomplished in other parts of our lives. We become accustomed to knowing what we’re doing. Then we try something new and discover we are terrible at it. There is something wonderfully hopeful about accepting that. Being bad at something is not evidence that you shouldn’t be doing it. It may simply be evidence that you have begun. Not everything needs to become a competence. Some things can remain pleasures.

Mind the Gaps

Another of Murray’s principles is accepting what we don’t know. This may be central to critical hope. If we knew an effort would succeed, hope wouldn’t be necessary. We don’t know whether the book will be good. We don’t know whether the business will succeed. We don’t know how good we can become at something. We don’t know whether the relationship will last. We don’t know whether the person we mentor will remember anything we taught them. We don’t know how much difference an act of kindness will make. We act anyway.

That is a fundamentally different relationship with uncertainty from spectatorship. The spectator eventually gets a result. The participant risks something. Perhaps that is why participation can be frightening. But perhaps it is also why it matters.

Freudenfreude—Then Come Home

This brings us back to where we began. Celebrate other people’s success. Really celebrate it. Be delighted when your friend succeeds. Take pride in your children and grandchildren. Marvel at extraordinary talent. Cheer when your team wins. Applaud the golfer who holes the impossible putt. Go to the concert. Enjoy excellence wherever you find it.

Someone else’s success need not diminish us. But neither does it need to substitute for us. Perhaps genuine freudenfreude becomes easier when we are sufficiently engaged in our own lives. We don’t need to envy another person’s accomplishment, because our lives have purposes of their own. We can applaud. And then come home.

Don’t Give Up the Ship

Murray’s final principle is persistence. Not because everything will work out. It won’t. Not because we can become anything we want. We can’t. There are limits imposed by ability, circumstances, opportunity, health, luck and time. Some possibilities disappear as we get older. Some things simply aren’t going to happen.

Hope does not require pretending otherwise. What remains hopeful is the conviction that possibility has not disappeared merely because some possibilities have. There are still things to learn. People to meet. Places to go. Relationships to deepen. Things to make. Things to understand. Ways to contribute. Reasons to laugh.

Perhaps every so often we should ask ourselves one simple question: what am I still looking forward to doing—not watching, not following, not buying a ticket to see someone else do, but doing myself? If the answer comes slowly, perhaps that’s worth noticing. And then perhaps we should find something. Not something extraordinary. Something ours.

A Life Actually Lived

There is nothing wrong with applauding extraordinary people. There is nothing wrong with being entertained, inspired or even awestruck by what another human being can do. There is nothing wrong with watching the game.

Just remember that you are not merely part of someone else’s audience. You have a life of your own. It will almost certainly never be watched by millions. Much of what matters most in it cannot be measured at all. You cannot know what will come of everything you attempt. Some of it will fail. Some of it will be inefficient. And if you keep trying new things, occasionally you will be spectacularly bad at them. Do them anyway. Spend some of your time, money, curiosity and emotional energy on your own experiences. Cheer for other people. But leave room to cheer for yourself. Perhaps hope begins with believing that our own lives—ordinary, imperfect, uncertain and largely unobserved—remain worthy of our investment. Perhaps that is what hope looks like.

Share this insight:

Scroll to Top