There was an extraordinary scene in Strasbourg this week. Mark Carney rose to address the European Parliament and received a standing ovation. When he finished, he received another. Parliamentarians crowded around him, shaking his hand and asking for selfies. One arrived wearing a Team Canada hockey jersey. At moments the reception seemed less like that normally afforded a visiting prime minister than a rock star. Why?
It is tempting to interpret almost everything Carney is doing internationally through the lens of Donald Trump. On that interpretation, Carney went to Europe to send Washington a message, show that Canada has alternatives, or perhaps pressure the Americans back to the negotiating table. I think that misses something much larger. Carney did not go to Strasbourg to talk to Donald Trump. He went to talk to Europe, and Europe appears to be listening.
Something Began at Davos
I think we first saw it clearly at Davos in January. Carney told the World Economic Forum that the old international order was not coming back. More important, he argued that the world’s middle powers were not helpless spectators while the great powers determined their futures. They could strengthen themselves at home, build relationships between themselves and collectively reduce the leverage that makes coercion possible.
That was a Canadian prime minister speaking, but it was not merely a Canadian message. It was an invitation. Eight months later, that invitation appears to be finding an audience. That is what makes Strasbourg important. We may be watching Carney become something more than a Canadian leader. An international leadership role appears to be emerging—not because anyone appointed him to it, but because he is articulating a problem that many countries recognize as their own and proposing a way through it.
The World Has Changed
For generations, Canada enjoyed the enormous advantage of living beside the world’s largest economy. We built extraordinarily integrated economies. The United States became overwhelmingly our largest customer.
There were excellent reasons for that. But somewhere along the way, concentration became dependence. We left too many eggs in one basket. Donald Trump did not create that vulnerability. He exposed it. Canada discovered what happens when another government is prepared to use tariffs, market access and economic integration as leverage. Carney’s response was not to preserve the old relationship at any price. Canada ultimately walked away from negotiations rather than accept terms it considered inconsistent with its sovereignty.
That has costs. Diversification will have costs too, but leadership begins by acknowledging something uncomfortable: the old world is not coming back simply because we liked it. The question is what we build next.
Sovereignty Means Having Choices
Canada is not turning away from the United States. Nor should it. Americans remain our neighbours, friends, allies and enormously important trading partners. Nothing about selling more Canadian products in Europe or Asia requires us to sell fewer to Americans.
This is not about replacing Washington with Brussels. It is about ensuring that Canada is never again so dependent upon Washington, Brussels, Beijing or anyone else that another government can dictate our choices. Sovereignty is not isolation. Sovereignty is having choices. That means strengthening Canada internally: removing unnecessary barriers between our provinces, developing our resources, building infrastructure and strengthening our industries and defence capacity.
Internationally, it means opening pathways. Europe is one. Asia is another. There will be more. Opening a pathway does not require Canada to walk down it. Exploring a relationship does not require accepting whatever terms might eventually be offered. Some opportunities will produce good agreements. Some will not. Canada retains the ability to say no. That is the point.
Complexity and Fear
There is another challenge in navigating a world this complicated. Most of us cannot be experts in international trade, constitutional law, defence procurement, energy security, artificial intelligence, critical minerals and international relations. Yet decisions in all of those areas affect us, and citizens in a democracy are entitled to participate in deciding the direction their country takes. Complexity should never become a reason to exclude them from the discussion. Nor should it become an opportunity to frighten them.
There is an old and effective political technique: emphasize how complicated an issue is, then reduce it to a simple and emotionally powerful threat. People may not understand all the details, they are told, but they can understand what they should fear. That substitutes emotion for understanding.
The developing relationship between Canada and Europe is complicated. Of course it is. It may eventually involve trade, defence, investment, regulatory cooperation, energy, technology, mobility and much more. Canadians should question and debate all of it, but we should debate what is actually being proposed.
We have already heard warnings about European taxes being imposed on Canadians, European laws governing us and European open-border immigration policies being forced upon Canada. There is presently no agreement requiring any of those things. More important, those warnings are incompatible with the direction Carney has consistently taken and the principles he has repeatedly articulated. This is a prime minister whose government walked away from negotiations with Canada’s overwhelmingly largest trading partner rather than accept terms it considered inconsistent with Canadian sovereignty. Carney has repeatedly said that Canada’s response must be to become more resilient, more independent and less vulnerable to the decisions of any other country. In Strasbourg he again said that deeper ties with Europe should “strengthen our sovereignty” while safeguarding our ability to live as we choose. Indeed, his description of the proposed alliance could hardly have been clearer: it should be strong enough that “no one can dictate our choices.”
The entire project is about increasing Canada’s freedom of action. It would turn that project on its head to suggest that, having refused to compromise Canadian sovereignty in Washington, Carney now intends to surrender control over Canadian taxation, Canadian law or Canadian immigration policy to Brussels. Nothing he has proposed suggests it. Nothing in the direction he has taken suggests it. His words repeatedly say the opposite.
Of course every eventual agreement should be scrutinized. Governments should always be held accountable for the commitments they make, but scrutiny requires something to scrutinize. If an eventual agreement gives Brussels authority to tax Canadians, show us the provision. If it makes Canadian law subordinate to European law, identify the mechanism. If it transfers control of Canadian immigration policy, point to the words that do so. Then Canadians can debate whether those terms are acceptable. Until then, presenting such possibilities as realistic dangers asks Canadians to fear something for which there is presently no evidentiary foundation.
A confident democracy should do better. Explain complicated things. Debate them. Challenge assumptions. Present competing evidence. Admit uncertainty where it exists, and trust people to think. The answer to complexity is not simplification. It is understanding.
Leadership
Former New Brunswick premier and former Canadian ambassador to Washington Frank McKenna recently spoke about what Canada particularly needs at this moment—leadership. That sounds almost too simple. Perhaps it is not. Leadership is not finding a slogan that makes a difficult problem disappear. It is helping people understand the problem without pretending it is simple. It sometimes means telling people things they would rather not hear.
The world has changed. The old relationship with the United States cannot simply be wished back into existence. Diversification will take years. It will cost money. There will be mistakes. Some new relationships will work better than others. Canada cannot know today precisely where all the new pathways will lead.
Then leadership does something else. It points in a direction. Build Canada. Open markets. Develop resources. Create infrastructure. Make new friends without discarding old ones. Reduce dependencies. Protect sovereignty. Create choices, and move.
That is what Carney is doing in Canada. Increasingly, it is also what he is talking about abroad.
Why Europe Was Cheering
Europe has its own dependencies and vulnerabilities. Europeans are confronting many of the same questions Canada is confronting: what does sovereignty mean when trade, energy, defence, technology, finance and supply chains can all become instruments of pressure?
Carney arrived in Strasbourg with the answer he began articulating at Davos. Not isolation. Not another empire. Not another great-power bloc. Instead, a network of sovereign countries strong enough individually and connected enough collectively that none can easily be coerced. Carney described it as “collective resilience.” Canada and Europe, he argued, can strengthen one another without either surrendering its independence.
There was an illuminating moment during his speech. Carney said he was not proposing another bloc that would become a great-power rival—“only with better manners.” The chamber reacted. It has been described as laughter. I heard something rather different: less the laughter that follows a joke than the uncomfortable recognition that follows when someone says aloud something everyone understands but seldom says. The words were light. The truth underneath them was not. Great powers can use economic and military strength to pressure smaller countries. Carney’s answer is not that the middle powers should become another great power and do the same thing. It is that they should become strong enough, together, that coercion becomes less effective.
Leadership Breeds Leadership
There may be something else happening here. Leadership breeds leadership. It is difficult to be the first country to acknowledge that an old assumption no longer works, to accept the costs of reducing a comfortable dependency, or to resist pressure from a much larger power when everyone else is waiting to see whether resistance is possible. But once someone does it, the calculation begins to change. One country opening a pathway makes it easier for another to open one. One country showing that sovereignty can be defended without hostility strengthens others prepared to do the same. One leader speaking candidly about a changed world makes it easier for other leaders to acknowledge it and act.
Carney is not asking Europe to follow Canada. He is arguing that Canada, Europe and other middle powers have more agency than they sometimes imagine. They do not have to choose between submission to a great power and retreat from the world. They can strengthen themselves at home, build relationships with one another and collectively reduce the leverage that makes coercion effective.
Canada cannot accomplish that alone. Neither can Europe. Former prime minister Stephen Harper made essentially the Canadian part of that argument this week. Supporting Canada’s decision to walk away from the U.S. negotiations, he said that maintaining Canadian sovereignty now requires “diminished reliance upon the United States.” That is significant because this should not be a Liberal or Conservative idea. It is a Canadian one, and increasingly, it may be something larger than that.
Perhaps the significance of Strasbourg was not simply that European parliamentarians were applauding Mark Carney. Perhaps they were recognizing something in his message that is already taking hold among them: middle powers have agency, dependence is not inevitable, and sovereignty can be strengthened through cooperation rather than isolation. They are not waiting for someone to give them permission to lead. They are beginning to lead themselves. Perhaps what we witnessed in Strasbourg was the recognition that Canada is prepared to lead alongside them.
Something Larger
That is why I keep returning to the images from Strasbourg—the standing ovations, the parliamentarians lining up to shake his hand, the selfies, the Team Canada jersey. Those things do not prove that every European parliamentarian agrees with Mark Carney. They certainly do not mean Europe will accept every Canadian proposal. But they tell us something. Something that began at Davos appears to be growing. Carney is Canada’s prime minister, and his first responsibility is to Canadians. But increasingly his audience is larger than Canada.
International leadership is not bestowed by a title. It emerges when circumstances create a need for direction and someone begins articulating a path that others recognize as useful to them too. Perhaps that is what those parliamentarians were responding to. Not a Canadian prime minister who had come to Europe to defy Donald Trump. Not a politician offering a simple answer to a complicated problem. A leader saying that the world has changed, that middle powers need not surrender to that change, and that there is another way forward. Build strength at home. Open pathways abroad. Multiply relationships. Protect sovereignty by creating choices, and have enough confidence in ordinary citizens to explain why.
That message began attracting international attention at Davos. In Strasbourg this week, it looked increasingly like international leadership.

